Now The Daily Mail Gets Its Arithmetic Wrong

I have written before about the apparent challenges the Daily Mail has with geography and with the law of Scotland.

Now we can add arithmetic to its list of “fails”.

 

Today’s story about the awful X-Factor shrieks the headline “Is this the most brutal X Factor bootcamp ever? Nearly half of contestants axed by judges before even singing”. (All emphases added)

Leaving aside for now the use of the word “brutal”, which is hyperbole beyond any ever in the world (you see what I did there?) the article goes further in the second paragraph, before disproving the headline and that statement in the very next paragraph!

Para 2 states:-

“But now, as the ITV talent show enters the latest stage of the competition, it seems this year’s bootcamp could be the most brutal ever – with half of the contestants axed before even singing for the judges again.”

Got it, it’s actually half of the acts, not just nearly half, sent home – goodness me, that is brutal!

Para 3:-

“The night before the 186 acts were due to take to the stage to perform for judges Gary Barlow, Tulisa Contostavlos, Kelly Rowland and Louis Walsh, the panel once again looked over tapes of the contestants’ first auditions and made the decision to send nearly 40 of the hopeful acts home.”

Wait a minute – nearly 40 out of 186…I can work this one out…that’s not even a quarter!

We don't really need a calculator for this one, do we?

Now I know this should not annoy me, but as the Mail claims to be the second most visited news site in the world, can they at least have the decency to have their stories be accurate?

One can imagine the Daily Mail attacking the BBC for a similar meaningless mistake. Of course here it is an over-egged story to get page views – one wonders if Sarah Bull, the writer of the article felt that saying that a quarter of the acts had been eliminated was not brutal?

At least some of the commenters on the story have made the same point, but no-one at the Mail has seen fit to correct the article at all.

Sigh…

 

Advertisements

5 Comments

Filed under Daily Mail, Press

5 responses to “Now The Daily Mail Gets Its Arithmetic Wrong

  1. oisin71

    186 acts or contestants is the question. A single act could have several contestants, such as a dance troupe.

    It is concievable that a small number of acts could have been axed, resulting in a large number of contestants being eliminated.

    If you had 186 contestants and eliminated 40 acts that result in 93 contestants going home, that is exactly half the contestants, but not necessarily half the acts.

    A deliberately brutal piece of ambiguous journalism to suit the headline.

    PS. I do not watch X-Factor, but do enjoy numerical puzzles!!

    • The headline refers to “contestants” as does paragraph 2. Para 3 does say that of the 186 “acts” 40 were sent home.

      As you say, it may be that these 40 acts contained one half of all the contestants in the 186 acts, though I understnd from my daughtrs who watch the progranmme that no massed bands or choirs have entered this year.

      I think it is a gross exaggeration by the Mail (for a change – ha) but perhaps a question for next year’s Standard Grade mathematics exam!

      And on the puzzle note – how many animals of each kind did Moses take on the Ark?

  2. oisin71

    PPS. I do not read the Daily Mail either.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s